Review of ‘55 Steps’

From the January-February 2019 issue of News & Letters

The movie 55 Steps, directed by Bille August, tells the story of Eleanor Riese, a mental health patient, and her court case, which won the right for California’s acute, competent mentally ill patients to have informed consent about their medications. This was at a time when most of the medical community considered the mentally ill to be incompetent to direct their healthcare and some doctors were beginning to advocate for a collaborative approach that included patients.

DISABLED MUST FIGHT FOR  THEIR RIGHTS

The “55 steps” of the title refer to those Eleanor climbed to get to court. She counted them to ameliorate her anxiety. We first see Riese, played by Helena Bonham Carter, dragged into a room at St. Mary’s Hospital, thrown onto a bed and forcibly medicated. Later Riese, who lived with chronic paranoid schizophrenia, anxiety and mild mental retardation, places a phone call requesting a patient’s rights lawyer, despite her distrust of lawyers because of a public defender who had not listened to her.

Colette Hughes, a former psychiatric nurse, played by Hilary Swank, is denied entry until she threatens to call the State Board of Hospitals. After being persuaded by Hughes to take the case, including that there were times Riese was medicated simply because she was sarcastic, Hughes’ colleague, a professor of Constitutional law, Mort Cohen, played by Jeffrey Tambor, comes on board the case.

During the three court cases, Riese and Hughes become friends. We see Riese as warm or obnoxious, sometimes hot-tempered or funny, in short a human being. Riese persuades Hughes to become less of a workaholic.

Riese vs. St. Mary’s Hospital and Medical Center goes all the way to the California Supreme Court, which refuses to review the lower court’s ruling and results in Riese’s victory. She emphasized she wanted to win for all who live with mental illness, not just herself,

MENTAL ILLNESS IS NOT SHAMEFUL

It is a shame that this movie, which tells a very important story, did not get wide distribution. Instead, it opened via streaming and then was briefly shown in a few movie houses and continues to be streamed. 55 Steps can be rented or purchased.

There is still such a stigma to mental illness that people do not feel comfortable talking about it. But mental illness needs to be discussed, including over the dinner table, if we are ever to truly grapple with it and realize the mentally ill are human beings with dignity equal to all human beings. That will help create a society that includes the mentally ill and provides quality healthcare for us. It is my hope, along with those associated with the film, that the film provokes a broad and powerful movement of and for the mentally ill. Eleanor Riese said it best: her belief in the “human right to be respected and the human duty to treat others with respect.”

—Kaitlin

One thought on “Review of ‘55 Steps’

  1. Securing the right of the mentally ill to give informed consent regarding their medications is significant. It will provide greater dignity for not just the patients but their families and friends, too. It should also help break down the divisions between doctors and patients and help everyone realize that medical care is a two-way street among human beings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *