Massacre of Jews measures the inhumanity of capitalism

October 29, 2018

by Gerry Emmett

The Oct. 27 massacre of 11 Jewish congregants at Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life synagogue is the single deadliest anti-Semitic attack in U.S. history. The motive, as stated by the terrorist himself, was a hatred of Jewish support for Middle Eastern and Latin American immigrants through the organization HIAS. That this vile act echoes what has become so mainstreamed in political rhetoric worldwide—the hatred of immigrants, and the promotion of ethnic chauvinism—is a measure of the inhumanity of that politics, and of this moment of capitalist degradation.

“BECAUSE…THEY WERE JEWS!” is the title David Friedmann called his series created to fight anti-Semitism and race hatred.

This terrorist attack raises the specter of the massacres at Srebrenica, Utoya Island, East Ghouta, and so many other racist, counter-revolutionary crimes, just as those crimes can only be fully understood in relation to the Holocaust.


Trump himself condemned this act. But he can’t distance himself from his share of responsibility. His courting of the “alt right” during the 2016 presidential campaign mobilized the racist dregs of society and fired their imagination with visions of state power reminiscent of 1930s fascism.

Trump’s ideologue Stephen Bannon was key to this. It first led to the murder of Heather Heyer in Charlottesville by another neo-Nazi. Since then, Trump has distanced himself from Bannon formally, though Bannon’s promotion of Trumpism continues to dredge up such hatred through the promotion of anti-immigrant forces in Europe, as well as through his online propaganda film for the U.S. midterm elections, Trump at War.

Some neo-Nazis, like the terrorist murderer in Pittsburgh, have become disillusioned as Bannon’s activity shifted from the center of U.S. power to the margins—and it is notable that Bannon’s own recent rallies in New York State have only drawn a few dozen. The massacre in Pittsburgh reflects the terrorist’s fading dream of a new Holocaust.

Several thousand protestors gathered at The Tree of Life synagogue on Oct. 30, 2018, to protest Donald Trump’s visit. So thick was the crowd that his motorcade was forced to go in a different direction. Photo:

Trump’s belated condemnation of anti-Semitism will, at best, serve only to drive these demons back partly underground. As Woody Guthrie, in the 1950s, wrote of Trump’s own father, “I suppose Old Man Trump knows just how much racial hate he stirred up in the bloodpot of human hearts when he drawed that color line here at his eighteen hundred family [housing] project.”

The capitalist ruling class remains unable to solve any fundamental social problem, either in peace or in war, and so keeps its bloodpots simmering in the racist underworld of history. Every hint of this, every whisper, every pointed silence of Trump and any other ruling class politician or ideologue must be utterly condemned.


This question is bigger than Trump and his personal responsibility, however. Karl Marx’s critique of bourgeois society, and his vision of social revolution, first took form in a grappling with the question of European anti-Semitism. It is inseparable from his vision of humanism as the “solution to the riddle of history.”

Concretely, the issue of anti-Semitism in Europe, with its culmination in Nazism and genocide, was as significant a test for “Marxists,” for the revolutionary movement, as was the Black Dimension in the U.S. through Abolitionism, the Civil War, and until today. As Raya Dunayevskaya, founder of Marxist-Humanism in the U.S., wrote in “The Roots of Anti-Semitism“:

Under the open sore of the persecution of a minority is hidden the greater truth of exploitation—that the exploiters, not the exploited, are the minority. Within this greater truth will be found the answer as to why a specific scapegoat is chosen at a particular time at each separate stage of capitalism’s development.

Too often nominal revolutionaries have failed this test, from the Second International in the 1890s declaring that anti-Semitism and “philo-Semitism” were equal problems (as though Europe suffered from “philo-Semitism”) to the counter-revolutionary Stalinist whispering campaigns against Trotsky in the 1920s, the Hitler-Stalin Pact in 1939 that gave Hitler the green light for the invasion of Poland, the post-World War II fabrication of the “doctors’ plot” and the night of the murdered poets in Russia, and the Rudolf Slansky trial in occupied Czechoslovakia.

Anti-Semitism was a measure of the transformation of social revolution into the worst form of counter-revolution. Any “Marxism” that decenters the issue of anti-Semitism declares itself theoretically and practically dead and without a future.

The massacre at the Tree of Life synagogue was a modern pogrom, with assault weapons, social media presence, and poisoned roots in the current stage of world counter-revolution represented by Trump, Putin, and their like. History has shown that only an absolute opposition, a revolution in permanence, can hope to uproot this inhuman horror.

–Oct. 29, 2018

2 thoughts on “Massacre of Jews measures the inhumanity of capitalism

  1. This long time friend now member of News and Letters is a Jew and a long time human rights /political activist! The article’s very good in calling the massacre a pogrom or Jew hunt, and showing Trump’s culpability! BUT, you don’t mention Christianity, the “Blood Libel” or Jews being the OTHER. historically! We have a different religion and some have different clothes. We don’t accept Jesus as a savior !!! We have been called “Christ killers since ancient times! The Crusaders traveled to the Holy Land to free it from Arab control! On the way they went though Arab villages slaughtering people, then they went through Jewish villages slaughtering people! We are still called “Christ killers”, Children of Satan etc. today. The Russian Orthodox church accused Jews of mixing the blood of Christian children in matzos (unleavened bread)! The Russian Church led in the killing and persecution of Jews!! Today some American Protestant ministers say Jews can’t go to heaven and worse! Of course we are number one target of Nazis , White Supremacists etc.!!!

  2. So awful, especially because deep divisions among the exploited undermine our powers to fight back effectively.. Why hasn’t the mainstream news made sure everyone knows that Muslim organizations nationwide are in solidarity with the Jewish communities? Or reminding us that Black Lives Matter fights but another form of hate–the daily prejudice and hate against Black Americans that has been ongoing? Or called out the 45th president that when he says “Democrats want to liquidate our borders” he means only 1 border, and that “liquidate” was the term used by Nazis to mean murdering all the Jewish inhabitants of cities and towns during World War II? Let’s insist on the whole picture!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *